1. Contains a confused or unfocused thesis or merely
restates the question
2. Provides minimal relevant information or merely
states facts
3. Provides little or no analysis, mostly
generalizations; treatment is imbalanced
4. May contain major errors
5. May be poorly organized and/or poorly written
Weakest Category (0-1)
1. Lacks a thesis or simply restates the question
2. Demonstrates an incompetent or inadequate
response
3. Has little or no understanding of the question
4. May contain substantial factual errors
5. Is poorly organized and/or poorly written